Subject: Digest for the period 6/16/2006 - 6/17/2006 Date: Sat, 17 Jun 2006 01:04:15 -0400 Table of contents ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. Who was on JudgeNet in 1994? (Ed Westemeier) 2. Re: Scoring, a statistical look (Owen) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Ed Westemeier Date: Thu, 15 Jun 2006 21:11:45 -0400 Subject: Who was on JudgeNet in 1994? I was searching for something today and found an old archive containing a post that really brought back memories. This is the subscriber list from JudgeNet on the date indicated. Look through it and see how many names you recognize. Obviously, most of the email addresses have changed, but what surprised me is how many are still active today. Ed ---------------------------------------------------------------- Date: Wed, 2 Feb 94 14:02:13 EST From: chuck`at`synchro.com (Chuck Cox) Subject: Who's Who ################################# ## ## ## JudgeNet ## ## the beer judge digest ## ## ## ## subscriber list ## ## ## ## (addresses prefaced with ## ## '#' are relayed) ## ## ## ################################# # ### Federation of Amateur Wine and Beer Guilds (FAWBG) - NL # # Master Wine Judge # victor.reijs`at`surfnet.nl (Victor Reijs) # ### National Guild of Wine and Beer Judges (NGWBJ) - UK # # Examiner # g.a.cooper`at`gre.ac.uk (Geoff Cooper) # ### Beer Judge Certification Program (BJCP) - USA # # Associate Director # stroud%gaia`at`polaroid.com (Steve Stroud) # # Committee Representative # rad_equipment`at`radmac1.ucsf.edu (Russ Wigglesworth) # # Master Judges # chuck`at`synchro.com (Chuck Cox) digest`at`hopfen.synchro.com (Mike Fertsch) hersh`at`x.org (Jay Hersh) # # National Judges # steved`at`longs.lance.colostate.edu (Steve Dempsey) judge-relay`at`semantic.rsi.com (Bob Gorman) isenhour`at`lambic.fnal.gov (John Isenhour) glo`at`lanl.gov (Gordon Olson) darrylri`at`microsoft.com (Darryl Richman) # # Certified Judges # tony`at`spss.com (Tony Babinec) baughmankr`at`conrad.appstate.edu (Kinney Baughman) beebed`at`ere.umontreal.ca (Dwight Beebe) bickham`at`msc.cornell.edu (Scott Bickham) bronson`at`iexist.att.com (Edward Bronson) lcarter`at`claven.idbsu.edu (Loren Carter) cave`at`psc.org (Jim Cave) devine`at`cs.berkeley.edu (Bob Devine) brewnews`at`aol.com (Phil Doersam) allen`at`darwin.sfbr.org (Allen Ford) gummitch`at`techbook.com (Jeff Frane) bguerin`at`orincon.com (Bob Guerin) hall`at`buffa.enet.dec.com (Dan Hall) mlh`at`cygnus.ta52.lanl.gov (Michael Hall) stevie`at`spss.com (Steve Hamburg) charris`at`u.washington.edu (Craig Harris) doug`at`techbook.com (Doug Henderson) att!drutx!homer (Jim Homer) 71230.1762`at`cis.com (Al Kinchen) korz`at`iepubj.att.com (Al Korzonas) slamb`at`milp.jsc.nasa.gov (Sean Lamb) jel3`at`cornell.edu (John Lenz) malodah`at`pacbell.com (Martin Lodahl) larrylf`at`taligent.com (Larry Lynch-Freshner) afmccaul`at`ilstu.edu (Tony McCauley) rhreed`at`icdc.delcoelect.com (Rob Reed) reeves`at`sstcx1.lanl.gov (Geoff Reeves) resch`at`craycos.com (Dave Resch) ross`at`mscf.med.upenn.edu (Andy Ross) aaswr`at`asuvm.inre.asu.edu (Steve Russell) tas`at`allwise.att.com (Tom Strasser) homebrew`at`tso.uc.edu (Ed Westemeier) boskoduck`at`aol.com (Julian Zelazny) # # Recognized Judges # bradley`at`adx.adelphi.edu (Rob Bradley) busch`at`daacdev1.stx.com (Jim Busch) calen`at`vnet.ibm.com (John Calen) jami`at`partyline.com (Jami Chism) gcb`at`fc.hp.com (Glenn Colon-Bonet) lynnd`at`ihs.com (Lynn Danielson) u52983`at`uicvm.uic.edu (Roger Deschner) edwardp`at`indy.navy.mil (Paul Edwards) jimme`at`ahpcrc.umn.edu (Jim Ellingson) tee`at`cray.com (Tony Ernst) nfarrell`at`charon.ppco.com (Norman Farrell) 71064.1725`at`compuserve.com (Chris Folta) froeh`at`jpats.ecc.naa.rockwell.com (Michael Froehlich) gelly`at`persoft.com (Mitch Gelly) brew`at`devine.columbiasc.ncr.com (Jim Griggers) jdg`at`grex.ann-arbor.mi.us (Joshua Grosse) cush`at`msc.edu (Cush Hamlen) jhinken`at`aol.com (Jim Hinken) ech`at`ac.dal.ca (Ed Hitchcock) holton`at`donald.aix.kingston.ibm.com (Greg Holton) rick`at`adc.com (Rick Larson) ligas`at`mcmail.cis.mcmaster.ca (Michael Ligas) edl`at`tekig5.pen.tek.com (Ed Lingel) tedm`at`hp-pcd.cv.hp.com (Ted Manahan) r.mcglew3`at`genie.geis.com (Ray McGlew) pmiller`at`mmm.com (Phil Miller) scott`at`gordian.com (Scott Murphy) andnator`at`genesis.mcs.com (Andrew Patrick) piatz`at`cray.com (Steve Piatz) garyrich`at`qdeck.com (Gary Rich) simpson`at`rb.unisys.com (Mark Simpson) skeel`at`fcrfv2.ncifcrf.gov (Alison Skeel) kurt.swanson`at`dna.lth.se (Kurt Swanson) envkas`at`sn634.utica.ge.com (Karl Sweitzer) wrs`at`gozer.mv.com (Bill Slack) gdtms`at`garlic.lcs.mit.edu (Greg Troxel) # # Apprentice Judges # rotherham`at`aol.com (Andrew Ashmall- Liversidge) atkinson`at`unt.edu (Sam Atkinson) jack`at`wubios.wustl.edu (Jack Baty) dbeedle`at`rs6000.cmp.ilstu.edu (Dave Beedle) jeremybb`at`leland.stanford.edu (Jeremy Bergsman) jeffbean`at`aol.com (Jeff Biegert) michael`at`wupsych.wustl.edu (Mike Biondo) bliss`at`convex.com (Brian Bliss) boes`at`rsoc.rockwell.com (Gregory Boes) embreed`at`sfovmic1.vnet.ibm.com (Emily Breed) bli`at`psuvm.psu.edu (Jeff Brendle) beb`at`pt.com (Bruce Buck) jbunn`at`seanews.akita.com (John Bunn) akcs.chrisc`at`vpnet.chi.il.us (Chris Campanelli) adc`at`mvuts.att.com (Alexander Carr) nchoksi`at`erenj.com (Neelan Choksi) attmail!scuzzy!cssc!cong (Brian Conger) zz11p9c`at`pentagon-emh6.army.mil (Peter Cooke) dalton`at`mtl.mit.edu (Timothy Dalton) psd1`at`midway.uchicago.edu (Pratik Dave) jdecarlo`at`mitre.org (John DeCarlo) tdenny`at`rigel.cs.pdx.edu (Tom Denny) aderr`at`bbn.com (Alan Derr) norman.dickenson`at`sonoma.edu (Norman Dickenson) ddimitr`at`heartland.bradley.edu (Daniel Dimitroff) fjdobner`at`ihlpa.att.com (Frank Dobner) donham`at`super.enet.dec.com (Perry Donham) pjd`at`lanl.gov (Paul Dotson) adugarm`at`worldbank.org (Delano Dugarm) montye`at`aol.com (Monty Edson) 73627.3144`at`compuserve.com (David Elliott) jelliott`at`hop.qgraph.com (John Elliott) jeloff`at`technikon-1.trsa.ac.za (Johan Eloff) darren`at`ua1vm.ua.edu (Darren Evans-Young) p00739`at`psilink.com (Charles Ewen) efarrell`at`ossi.com (Liz Farrell) bruticus`at`hebron.connected.com (John Farver) # bruce.feist`at`f615.n109.z1.fidonet.org (Bruce Feist) gjfix`at`utamat.uta.edu (George Fix) jfleck`at`bigcat.missouri.edu (John Fleck) kfontaine`at`aol.com (Keith Fontaine) rich`at`beerich.demon.co.uk (Rich Fortnum) carlo.fusco`at`canrem.com (Carlo Fusco) kgalbraith`at`aol.com (Kevin Galbraith) 76702.764`at`compuserve.com (Robin Garr) rgarvin`at`btg.com (Rick Garvin) rgarvin`at`access.digex.net (Rick Garvin) jason`at`gibson.sde.hp.com (Jason Goldman) # polly.goldman`at`p2.f615.n109.z1.fidonet.org (Polly Goldman) goss`at`aol.com (Todd Gossett) agrant`at`mta.ca (Andrew Grant) green`at`hpmtaa.lvld.hp.com (Bob Green) juglr`at`intgp1.att.com (John Gunser) sunilg`at`access.digex.com (Sunil Gupta) joseph-judge`at`joebloe.maple-shade.nj.us (Joseph Hall) lhart`at`caticsuf.csufresno.edu (Lowell Hart) hilliard`at`zookeeper.zoo.uga.edu (Steve Hilliard) dhholscl`at`rs6000.cmp.ilstu.edu (David Holsclaw) marhug`at`telecom.usu.edu (Marc Hugentobler) mri10`at`mfg.amdahl.com (Mike Inglis) spj`at`aol.com (Steve Jackson) keinert`at`iastate.edu (Fritz Keinert) mike.keller`at`genie.geis.com (Mike Keller) kesicki`at`psc.psc.scarolina.edu (Ed Kesicki) kitchwa`at`bongo.cc.utexas.edu (Bill Kitch) jlandreman`at`atmel.com (John Landreman) jal`at`techbook.com (Jim Larsen) mol`at`jyu.fi (Mika Latokartano) trl`at`photos.wustl.edu (Tom Leith) jliddil`at`azcc.arizona.edu (James Liddil) linc`at`raphael.acpub.duke.edu (Christine Lin) uunet!csfb1!dlin (Dixon Lin) ktl`at`kittyhawk.aero.rmit.oz.au (Katie Lord) v-ccsl`at`microsoft.com (Scott Lord) magdek`at`lonexa.admin.rl.af.mil (Kevin Madge) magee`at`helix.mgh.harvard.edu (John Magee) cjohnm`at`ccit.arizona.edu (John Mare) ak200032`at`sol.yorku.ca (Alan Marshall) klm`at`gozer.mv.com (Kevin McBride) tjm17`at`jaguar.uofs.edu (Terence McCabe) daniel.f.mcconnell`at`med.umich.edu (Daniel McConnell) berniem`at`microsoft.com (Bernie McIlroy) tmitchel`at`bbn.com (Tom Mitchell) morgan`at`spectra.com (Mike Morgan) philipm978`at`aol.com (Philip Murray) bmyers`at`uclink.berkeley.edu (Brian Myers) rcm`at`col.hp.com (Rick Myers) koconnor`at`mailbox.syr.edu (Kieran O'Connor) edo`at`marcam.com (Ed Oriordan) jimmyp`at`netcom.com (Jimmy Patrick) bpeck`at`cisco.com (Barrett Peck) raudins`at`elan2.coryphaeus.com (Glenn Raudins) u2102952`at`csdvax.csd.unsw.edu.au (Phil Reichert) ridgely`at`a1.cber.fda.gov (Bill Ridgely) roy.rudebusch`at`travel.com (Roy Rudebusch) lennart`at`btjsys.btj.se (Lennart Sandberg) p00644`at`psilink.com (Phillip Seitz) shaver`at`cirr.com (Dave Shaver) jimsnow`at`aol.com (Jim Snow) u18183%uicvm`at`uic.edu (Paul Sovcik) 70740.1107`at`compuserve.com (James Spence) gak`at`wrs.com (Richard Stueven) suurb`at`farallon.com (Dave Suurballe) sweenerb`at`msuvx1.memst.edu (Bob Sweeney) btalk`at`aol.com (Bob Talkiewicz) spencer.w.thomas`at`med.umich.edu (Spencer Thomas) tuecks`at`mathematik.uni-kl.de (Markus Tuecks) cvirgilio`at`electriciti.com (Charles Virgilio) mark_wallace`at`crd.lotus.com (Mark Wallace) walls`at`e7sa.epi.syr.ge.com (Scott Walls) walter`at`lamar.colostate.edu (Brian Walter) weaver`at`spdc.ti.com (Tyler Weaver) chuck.wettergreen`at`aquila.com (Chuck Wettergreen) david.whatley`at`natinst.com (David Whatley) swh`at`ll.mit.edu (Sarah White) rwick`at`aol.com (Ron Wickert) winstead%brauerei.uucp`at`cs.tulane.edu (Teddy Winstead) yost`at`marcam.com (Ed Yost) zamick`at`yoko.rutgers.edu (Jonathan Zamick) zipfel`at`cs.wisc.edu (Gary Zipfel) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Owen Date: Fri, 16 Jun 2006 07:54:37 -0400 Subject: Re: Scoring, a statistical look Spencer W. Thomas asks for scoring data to check his analysis. I drew the following from MALT's Blue Ridge Brew Off Competition Database for the past three years consisting of 1225 entries. Outstanding: 1%, 2.1 to 2.8 sigma Excellent: 16%, 1.1 to 2.1 sigma Very Good: 38%, 0 to 1.1 sigma Good: 37%, -1.3 to 0 sigma Fair: 7%, -2.3 to -1.3 sigma Problematic: 1%, -4.2 to -2.3 sigma It does appear that +2.5 sigma equates to "World Class" and the distribution is about "normal" with bias for higher scores. Owen Halpeny Mountain Ale and Lager Tasters Asheville NC PS Out next Blue Ridge Brew Off is set for September. Watch this space for details. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ***** Important Subscriber Information ***** To post a message to JudgeNet, send it to judge`at`synchro.com. Send plain text only, no HTML, MIME, encoded text or attachments. Make sure you use a meaningful subject. Quote only as much material as is needed for context. To manage your subscription, go to http://synchro.com/judge/subscriptions.html or send an email to judge-request`at`synchro.com with the subject: help judge. JudgeNet is also available as an NNTP newsgroup, go to news://news.synchro.com/synchro.judge